Skip links

Bearings for Electric Motors: Mastering Selection and Maintenance

Electric motor bearings are the unsung heroes of the machinery world, quietly ensuring the smooth operation of everything from industrial pumps to household appliances. Let’s delve into the fascinating world of electric motor bearings to understand their types and the pivotal role they play in the performance of these motors.

Types of Bearings Used in Electric Motors

When it comes to electric motor bearings, one size definitely does not fit all. Here are the main types you’re likely to encounter:

Ball Bearings: Principles and Applications

Ball bearings are the rock stars of the bearing world, known for their versatility and efficiency. They consist of small metal balls housed within two rings, allowing for smooth rotation with minimal friction. Ball bearings are ideal for applications requiring high-speed rotation and moderate radial loads. From ceiling fans to power tools, ball bearings keep the world spinning smoothly.

Roller Bearings: Varieties and Functionality

Roller bearings, as the name suggests, utilize cylindrical rollers instead of balls to facilitate motion. This design enables roller bearings to handle heavier radial loads and shock loads with ease. From tapered roller bearings in automotive transmissions to cylindrical roller bearings in conveyor systems, these bearings excel in applications where durability and load-carrying capacity are paramount.

Sleeve Bearings: Characteristics and Advantages

Sleeve bearings, also known as bushings, take a simpler approach to motion control. Instead of balls or rollers, they feature a cylindrical sleeve that fits snugly around a rotating shaft. While not as flashy as their ball and roller counterparts, sleeve bearings offer excellent reliability and cost-effectiveness. You’ll often find them in low-speed, high-load applications such as industrial fans and pumps.

Importance of Bearings in Electric Motor Performance

Now that we’ve covered the basics of electric motor bearings, let’s explore why they’re so crucial for optimal performance:

Role in Efficiency and Energy Consumption

Think of bearings as the grease that keeps the wheels of your electric motor turning smoothly. By minimizing friction and reducing energy loss, high-quality bearings can significantly improve the efficiency of a motor. This translates to lower operating costs and reduced environmental impact—a win-win for both your wallet and the planet.

Impact on Noise and Vibration Levels

Ever heard the soothing hum of a well-oiled machine? You can thank the bearings for that. By damping vibrations and minimizing noise, quality bearings contribute to a quieter, more pleasant working environment. Whether you’re designing a whisper-quiet HVAC system or a noise-sensitive laboratory instrument, choosing the right bearings can make all the difference.

Influence on Maintenance Requirements

Nobody likes unexpected downtime due to equipment failure. Fortunately, investing in premium bearings can help minimize maintenance headaches. By reducing wear and tear on critical components, high-quality bearings extend the lifespan of your electric motor and reduce the need for costly repairs. It’s like giving your motor a built-in insurance policy against unplanned downtime.

In conclusion, electric motor bearings may seem like small components, but their impact on performance, efficiency, and reliability is anything but insignificant. Whether you’re building a cutting-edge robotics platform or a humble household appliance, choosing the right bearings is key to unlocking peak performance and longevity. So the next time you fire up your favorite gadget, take a moment to appreciate the unsung heroes keeping it running smoothly.

Selection Criteria for Electric Motor Bearings

When it comes to selecting the right bearings for your electric motor, it’s not a one-size-fits-all scenario. Various factors must be considered to ensure optimal performance and longevity. Let’s dive into the key selection criteria that will help you choose the perfect bearings for your application.

Load Capacity and Speed Requirements

Calculating Load Capacities for Various Bearings

Before choosing a bearing, it’s essential to determine the load it will be subjected to during operation. Different types of bearings have varying load capacities, which must match the demands of your specific application. Whether it’s radial loads, axial loads, or a combination of both, understanding the load requirements is crucial for selecting the right bearing.

For example, ball bearings are excellent for applications with moderate radial and axial loads, while roller bearings excel in handling heavier loads. By calculating the expected loads and comparing them with the rated capacities of different bearings, you can ensure optimal performance and prevent premature failure.

Matching Bearings to Operational Speeds

Speed kills, they say, and the same holds true for bearings. Operating at high speeds can generate heat and friction, leading to premature wear and failure if the bearings aren’t up to the task. When selecting bearings for your electric motor, it’s essential to match them to the operational speeds they’ll encounter.

Ball bearings are well-suited for high-speed applications due to their low friction and smooth operation. On the other hand, roller bearings are better equipped to handle lower speeds and heavier loads. By considering the speed requirements of your motor and choosing bearings with the appropriate design and materials, you can ensure reliable performance without sacrificing efficiency.

Environmental Considerations

Temperature and Lubrication Compatibility

Electric motors often operate in diverse environmental conditions, from scorching industrial settings to frigid outdoor installations. Temperature fluctuations can have a significant impact on bearing performance, affecting lubrication viscosity and material properties.

When selecting bearings, it’s crucial to consider their temperature and lubrication compatibility. High-temperature environments may require bearings with special heat-resistant materials or lubricants designed to withstand extreme conditions. Conversely, low-temperature applications demand bearings that remain flexible and lubricated even in freezing temperatures.

Corrosion Resistance and Environmental Contaminants

In harsh industrial environments or outdoor settings, bearings are exposed to moisture, chemicals, and other environmental contaminants that can accelerate wear and corrosion. To ensure long-term reliability, it’s essential to choose bearings with adequate corrosion resistance and sealing mechanisms.

Stainless steel bearings are commonly used in corrosive environments due to their excellent resistance to rust and chemicals. Additionally, sealed or shielded bearings can prevent contaminants from infiltrating the bearing assembly, prolonging its lifespan and reducing maintenance requirements.

Fit, Tolerance, and Mounting Considerations

Precision Fit Requirements for Bearings

Proper fit and tolerance are critical for maximizing the performance and lifespan of electric motor bearings. A precise fit ensures that the bearings can transmit loads efficiently without excessive play or misalignment.

When selecting bearings, consider factors such as shaft and housing tolerances, as well as clearance requirements. Too tight of a fit can increase friction and lead to premature wear, while excessive clearance can result in vibration and reduced stability. By adhering to recommended fit and tolerance guidelines, you can optimize the performance of your electric motor and prevent premature failure.

Proper Mounting Techniques to Ensure Longevity

Even the highest-quality bearings can fail prematurely if they’re not properly mounted and installed. Improper mounting can lead to misalignment, excessive preload, or insufficient lubrication, all of which can significantly impact bearing performance and lifespan.

When mounting bearings in your electric motor, follow manufacturer recommendations and best practices. Ensure that shafts and housings are clean and free of burrs or debris that could interfere with proper seating. Use appropriate tools and techniques to achieve the correct preload and alignment, and verify that the bearings are adequately lubricated before putting them into service.

By paying attention to these critical selection criteria, you can choose the right bearings for your electric motor application and ensure reliable performance for years to come. Whether you’re designing a new system or upgrading an existing one, investing in high-quality bearings tailored to your specific needs is key to achieving optimal efficiency and longevity.

Maintenance and Lubrication Practices for Electric Motor Bearings

Maintenance and lubrication are essential aspects of ensuring the smooth and reliable operation of electric motor bearings. Neglecting proper care can lead to premature wear, increased friction, and costly downtime. Let’s explore the importance of maintenance and lubrication practices and delve into the specific techniques and considerations for keeping electric motor bearings in top condition.

Importance of Proper Lubrication

Types of Lubricants Suitable for Electric Motor Bearings

Lubrication is the lifeblood of bearings, providing crucial protection against friction and wear. Choosing the right lubricant is paramount to ensure optimal performance and longevity of electric motor bearings.

  • Grease: Grease is the most common lubricant used in electric motor bearings due to its ability to retain viscosity over a wide range of temperatures. Lithium-based greases are often preferred for their excellent lubricating properties and compatibility with most bearing materials.
  • Oil: Oil lubrication offers superior cooling and flushing properties compared to grease. It is commonly used in high-speed or high-temperature applications where grease may not be suitable. Synthetic oils, such as polyalphaolefin (PAO) or ester-based oils, are preferred for their thermal stability and resistance to oxidation.

Lubrication Frequency and Application Methods

Proper lubrication is not a one-and-done affair—it requires regular attention and maintenance to ensure optimal performance. The frequency of lubrication depends on factors such as operating speed, load, temperature, and environmental conditions.

  • Regular Inspection: Regularly inspect bearings for signs of inadequate lubrication, such as overheating, abnormal noise, or vibration. These may indicate a lack of lubricant or the presence of contaminants.
  • Re-lubrication Schedule: Follow manufacturer recommendations for re-lubrication intervals, typically ranging from months to years depending on the application. Implementing a proactive re-lubrication schedule can prevent premature bearing failure and extend lifespan.
  • Proper Application Methods: When applying lubricant, ensure thorough coverage of all bearing surfaces while avoiding over-greasing, which can lead to overheating and excessive friction. Use appropriate tools and techniques to evenly distribute lubricant and minimize waste.

Bearing Inspection and Monitoring

Signs of Wear and Failure: Visual Inspection Guidelines

Visual inspection is a crucial part of bearing maintenance, allowing early detection of potential issues before they escalate into catastrophic failures. By familiarizing yourself with common signs of wear and failure, you can proactively address issues and prevent costly downtime.

  • Abnormal Noise: Listen for unusual sounds such as grinding, squeaking, or rumbling, which may indicate bearing wear or misalignment.
  • Excessive Vibration: Feel for excessive vibration or oscillation during operation, which can signal bearing damage or misalignment.
  • Temperature Fluctuations: Monitor bearing temperature using handheld infrared thermometers or thermal imaging cameras. An abnormal increase in temperature may indicate inadequate lubrication or excessive friction.

Utilizing Condition Monitoring Technologies

In addition to visual inspection, leveraging advanced condition monitoring technologies can provide deeper insights into bearing health and performance.

  • Vibration Analysis: Utilize vibration analysis tools to detect abnormal vibration patterns indicative of bearing wear, misalignment, or imbalance. By analyzing frequency spectra and amplitude levels, you can pinpoint potential issues and take corrective action.
  • Infrared Thermography: Use infrared thermography to monitor bearing temperature non-invasively. Hot spots or temperature gradients may indicate inadequate lubrication, excessive friction, or impending bearing failure.
  • Ultrasonic Testing: Employ ultrasonic testing to detect early signs of bearing fatigue, such as micro-fractures or surface defects. Ultrasonic sensors can detect subtle changes in acoustic emissions, providing early warning of potential failures.

In conclusion, proper maintenance and lubrication practices are essential for ensuring the smooth and reliable operation of electric motor bearings. By choosing the right lubricants, adhering to recommended lubrication schedules, and implementing thorough inspection and monitoring protocols, you can maximize bearing lifespan, minimize downtime, and optimize overall equipment performance.

Common Issues and Failure Modes of Electric Motor Bearings

Electric motor bearings are subjected to various stresses and environmental conditions during operation, making them susceptible to a range of issues and failure modes. Understanding these common challenges is essential for ensuring the reliable performance of electric motors. Let’s explore some of the most prevalent issues and failure modes encountered in electric motor bearings and discuss strategies for mitigation.

Overloading and Overheating

Effects of Overloading on Bearing Lifespan

Overloading occurs when bearings are subjected to excessive radial or axial loads beyond their rated capacity. This can result from factors such as improper sizing, misalignment, or sudden shock loads. Overloading places undue stress on the bearing components, leading to accelerated wear and reduced lifespan.

  • Fatigue Failure: Excessive loading can cause rolling elements and raceways to deform or develop cracks over time, leading to fatigue failure. This manifests as spalling, pitting, or flaking of bearing surfaces, compromising performance and reliability.
  • Increased Friction: Overloaded bearings experience higher levels of friction, generating heat that can degrade lubricants and accelerate wear. This vicious cycle exacerbates bearing damage and can ultimately lead to catastrophic failure.

Mitigation Strategies for Overheating Issues

Preventing overloading and overheating is critical for maintaining the health and longevity of electric motor bearings. Implementing proactive mitigation strategies can help mitigate these issues and ensure optimal performance.

  • Proper Sizing: Ensure that bearings are properly sized and rated for the expected loads and operating conditions. Consult manufacturer specifications and engineering guidelines to select bearings with adequate load capacities and safety factors.
  • Alignment and Installation: Proper alignment of shafts and housings is essential for distributing loads evenly across bearing surfaces. Use precision alignment tools and techniques to minimize misalignment and reduce stress on bearings.
  • Temperature Monitoring: Monitor bearing temperatures regularly using handheld thermometers or embedded sensors. Implement temperature alarms or shutdown mechanisms to prevent overheating and mitigate potential damage.

Contamination and Ingress of Foreign Particles

Sources of Contamination and Their Impact

Contamination from foreign particles such as dust, dirt, moisture, and abrasive particles can wreak havoc on electric motor bearings. These contaminants can infiltrate bearing assemblies through various pathways, including improper sealing, shaft seals, or ingress during maintenance procedures.

  • Abrasive Wear: Particulate contaminants act as abrasives, gradually wearing down bearing surfaces and causing premature failure. This can result in increased friction, heat generation, and loss of lubrication effectiveness.
  • Corrosion: Moisture and chemical contaminants can promote corrosion of bearing components, leading to pitting, rusting, or degradation of surface finishes. Corrosion accelerates wear and compromises bearing integrity, posing a significant risk to motor performance.

Preventive Measures to Minimize Contamination

Minimizing contamination is essential for preserving the integrity and performance of electric motor bearings. Implementing preventive measures can help mitigate the risk of contamination and extend bearing lifespan.

  • Effective Sealing: Ensure that bearing assemblies are adequately sealed to prevent ingress of contaminants. Use labyrinth seals, rubber gaskets, or lip seals to create a barrier against dust, moisture, and other foreign particles.
  • Regular Maintenance: Implement a comprehensive maintenance schedule that includes regular inspection and cleaning of bearing assemblies. Remove accumulated debris, grease buildup, and other contaminants to prevent their ingress into bearing surfaces.
  • Environment Control: Control environmental factors such as temperature, humidity, and cleanliness to minimize the risk of contamination. Use environmental enclosures, filters, or ventilation systems to create a clean operating environment for electric motor bearings.

By addressing common issues such as overloading, overheating, and contamination, you can ensure the reliable performance and longevity of electric motor bearings. Implementing proactive mitigation strategies and preventive maintenance measures is key to minimizing downtime, reducing repair costs, and maximizing overall equipment effectiveness.

Advancements and Innovations in Electric Motor Bearing Technology

Electric motor bearing technology has undergone significant advancements in recent years, driven by the demand for higher performance, reliability, and efficiency. Let’s explore some of the latest innovations shaping the future of electric motor bearings.

Integration of Sensor Technologies for Condition Monitoring

Real-time Performance Monitoring Systems

Gone are the days of reactive maintenance, where bearings were replaced only after failure. Today, electric motor bearings are equipped with advanced sensor technologies that enable real-time performance monitoring.

  • Vibration Sensors: Embedded vibration sensors detect abnormal vibration patterns, indicating potential bearing wear or misalignment. Real-time data analytics algorithms analyze vibration signatures to predict impending failures and trigger maintenance alerts.
  • Temperature Sensors: Integrated temperature sensors monitor bearing temperatures, providing insights into lubrication effectiveness and detecting overheating conditions. By tracking temperature trends, maintenance teams can identify early warning signs of bearing degradation and take preventive action.

Predictive Maintenance Capabilities

Predictive maintenance has emerged as a game-changer in the field of electric motor bearing maintenance. By leveraging sensor data and predictive analytics, maintenance teams can anticipate bearing failures before they occur, minimizing downtime and optimizing equipment performance.

  • Machine Learning Algorithms: Advanced machine learning algorithms analyze sensor data to identify patterns and anomalies indicative of impending bearing failures. By continuously learning from historical data, these algorithms can improve predictive accuracy over time, enabling more proactive maintenance strategies.
  • Condition-based Alerts: Predictive maintenance systems generate condition-based alerts when bearings exhibit early warning signs of degradation. Maintenance teams receive actionable insights and recommendations for timely intervention, such as lubrication replenishment or bearing replacement, to prevent costly downtime.

Material Developments and Nanotechnology Applications

Enhanced Durability and Performance Through Advanced Materials

Traditional bearing materials have limitations in terms of durability, friction resistance, and load-carrying capacity. However, advancements in material science have led to the development of innovative bearing materials with superior performance characteristics.

  • Ceramic Bearings: Ceramic bearings, made from materials such as silicon nitride or zirconia, offer exceptional hardness, corrosion resistance, and thermal stability compared to traditional steel bearings. They excel in high-speed, high-temperature applications and provide extended service life and reduced maintenance requirements.
  • Polymer Bearings: Polymer bearings, reinforced with fibers or fillers, offer lightweight, corrosion-resistant alternatives to metal bearings. They exhibit low friction coefficients, minimal wear rates, and excellent chemical resistance, making them ideal for applications in harsh environments or sensitive industries such as food and pharmaceuticals.

Nanoscale Coatings for Reduced Friction and Wear

Nanotechnology has revolutionized bearing surface engineering, enabling the development of nanoscale coatings that enhance lubrication effectiveness, reduce friction, and mitigate wear.

  • Diamond-like Carbon (DLC) Coatings: DLC coatings provide a durable, low-friction surface layer that improves the tribological properties of bearing components. They reduce frictional losses, increase wear resistance, and promote efficient energy transfer, resulting in improved motor efficiency and extended bearing lifespan.
  • Molecular Lubricant Films: Molecular lubricant films, applied using advanced deposition techniques such as molecular beam epitaxy, form ultra-thin, self-healing layers on bearing surfaces. These films provide superior boundary lubrication properties, reducing friction and wear in extreme operating conditions.

By embracing these advancements in electric motor bearing technology, manufacturers can achieve higher levels of performance, reliability, and efficiency in their equipment. From real-time condition monitoring to innovative materials and coatings, these innovations pave the way for a future where electric motors operate more reliably and sustainably than ever before.

Best Practices for Extending the Lifespan of Electric Motor Bearings

Ensuring the longevity and reliability of electric motor bearings is essential for the smooth operation of machinery and equipment. By following best practices for installation, maintenance, and replacement, you can extend the lifespan of electric motor bearings and optimize equipment performance. Let’s explore some of these best practices in detail.

Proper Installation Techniques

Alignment Procedures and Importance of Shaft Straightness

Proper alignment is paramount to the performance and longevity of electric motor bearings. Misalignment can result in uneven loading, increased friction, and premature wear. To ensure optimal alignment:

  • Utilize Precision Alignment Tools: Invest in precision alignment tools such as dial indicators or laser alignment systems to accurately align shafts and bearings. Proper alignment minimizes radial and axial loads on bearings, reducing the risk of premature failure.
  • Check Shaft Straightness: Before installation, inspect shafts for straightness using precision measurement tools. Bent or distorted shafts can cause misalignment and uneven loading on bearings, leading to accelerated wear and reduced lifespan.

Balancing Considerations for Optimal Performance

Balancing is another critical aspect of bearing installation that directly impacts performance and lifespan. Unbalanced rotating components can cause vibration, noise, and increased stress on bearings. To achieve optimal balance:

  • Dynamic Balancing: Prior to installation, ensure that rotating components such as shafts, rotors, and impellers are dynamically balanced to minimize vibration and stress on bearings. Balanced components reduce the risk of premature wear and prolong bearing lifespan.
  • Use Quality Components: Select high-quality components with tight tolerances and minimal manufacturing defects. Well-balanced components minimize vibration and harmonics, reducing the risk of bearing damage and extending lifespan.

Regular Maintenance Regimens

Scheduled Lubrication and Inspection Protocols

Regular lubrication and inspection are essential for maintaining the health and performance of electric motor bearings. Proper lubrication reduces friction, dissipates heat, and protects against wear. To establish a robust maintenance regimen:

  • Follow Manufacturer Guidelines: Adhere to manufacturer-recommended lubrication intervals and lubricant types. Use high-quality lubricants compatible with bearing materials and operating conditions to ensure optimal performance.
  • Implement Inspection Protocols: Establish routine inspection protocols to detect early signs of bearing wear or damage. Inspect bearings for abnormal noise, vibration, temperature, or visual signs of wear such as discoloration or pitting. Early detection allows for timely intervention and prevents catastrophic failure.

Timely Replacement of Bearings Before Catastrophic Failure

While regular maintenance can prolong bearing lifespan, all bearings have a finite lifespan and will eventually require replacement. Timely replacement before catastrophic failure is essential for preventing costly downtime and equipment damage. To determine the appropriate replacement schedule:

  • Monitor Bearing Condition: Continuously monitor bearing condition through regular inspections and condition monitoring technologies. Track factors such as vibration, temperature, and lubrication effectiveness to assess bearing health and performance.
  • Establish Replacement Criteria: Develop criteria for determining when bearings should be replaced based on factors such as operating hours, load conditions, and performance degradation. Replace bearings proactively before they reach the end of their service life to avoid unexpected failures.

By implementing proper installation techniques, establishing regular maintenance regimens, and replacing bearings in a timely manner, you can extend the lifespan of electric motor bearings and optimize equipment performance. These best practices help minimize downtime, reduce repair costs, and ensure the reliability of machinery and equipment in various industrial applications.

Resources and References for Electric Motor Bearings

When it comes to understanding electric motor bearings and ensuring their optimal performance, having access to reliable resources and references is invaluable. Whether you’re a maintenance technician, engineer, or enthusiast, these resources can provide valuable insights and guidance to help you navigate the complexities of electric motor bearings.

Industry Standards and Guidelines

ANSI/ABMA Standards for Bearing Selection and Application

The American National Standards Institute (ANSI) and the American Bearing Manufacturers Association (ABMA) have established comprehensive standards for bearing selection, installation, and maintenance. These standards serve as a valuable reference for engineers and maintenance professionals involved in electric motor applications.

  • Bearing Selection Criteria: ANSI/ABMA standards outline the criteria for selecting bearings based on factors such as load capacity, speed ratings, and lubrication requirements. Understanding these criteria is essential for choosing the right bearings for specific motor applications.
  • Installation and Mounting Guidelines: ANSI/ABMA standards provide guidelines for proper bearing installation, including mounting techniques, shaft tolerances, and preload settings. Adhering to these guidelines ensures optimal bearing performance and longevity.
  • Maintenance Practices: ANSI/ABMA standards also cover maintenance practices such as lubrication intervals, inspection procedures, and troubleshooting guidelines. By following these recommendations, maintenance teams can minimize downtime and extend bearing lifespan.

IEEE Guidelines for Electric Motor Maintenance

The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) offers comprehensive guidelines for electric motor maintenance, including best practices for bearing care and maintenance. These guidelines are invaluable resources for maintenance professionals and equipment operators seeking to optimize electric motor performance.

  • Vibration Analysis Techniques: IEEE guidelines provide recommendations for conducting vibration analysis to assess bearing health and detect early signs of wear or damage. By monitoring vibration levels and frequency spectra, maintenance teams can identify potential issues and take corrective action.
  • Lubrication Management: IEEE guidelines outline best practices for lubrication management, including lubricant selection, application methods, and replenishment schedules. Proper lubrication is essential for reducing friction, dissipating heat, and protecting against wear.
  • Condition Monitoring Strategies: IEEE guidelines advocate for the implementation of condition monitoring strategies such as temperature monitoring, oil analysis, and acoustic emission testing. These techniques enable proactive maintenance and early detection of bearing faults, minimizing downtime and repair costs.

Recommended Reading and Further Learning

Notable Texts and Publications on Electric Motor Bearings

A wealth of literature exists on the subject of electric motor bearings, offering in-depth insights into bearing design, performance characteristics, and maintenance strategies. Some notable texts and publications include:

  • “Bearing Design in Machinery: Engineering Tribology and Lubrication” by Avraham Harnoy: This comprehensive guide covers bearing design principles, material selection, lubrication techniques, and failure analysis, making it an essential resource for engineers and designers.
  • “Electric Motor Maintenance and Troubleshooting” by Augie Hand: This practical handbook provides guidance on electric motor maintenance, including bearing care, alignment procedures, and troubleshooting techniques. It serves as a valuable reference for maintenance technicians and equipment operators.

Online Resources and Communities for Industry Insights

In addition to printed materials, online resources and communities offer a wealth of information and industry insights on electric motor bearings. Some valuable online resources include:

  • Bearing Manufacturer Websites: Many bearing manufacturers offer technical resources, white papers, and application guides on their websites, providing valuable insights into bearing selection, installation, and maintenance best practices.
  • Industry Forums and Discussion Groups: Online forums and discussion groups such as LinkedIn groups, Reddit communities, and industry-specific forums provide opportunities for professionals to share knowledge, ask questions, and exchange insights on electric motor bearings.

By leveraging these resources and references, professionals can enhance their understanding of electric motor bearings, implement best practices for maintenance and care, and optimize equipment performance for increased reliability and longevity. Whether you’re a seasoned engineer or a novice technician, these resources offer valuable guidance and support in navigating the complex world of electric motor bearings.

Leave a comment